TAUB: Pressure. I need pressure.
JESSICA: Give me sutures...
TAUB: We need an Epi.
JESSICA: Alert trauma.
(EXHALES)
(BEEPS)
Let the record show that we are officially
convening a disciplinary hearing
regarding the events on February 3rd, 2012, in patient room 209.
Dr. House, this recording will be transcribed and published
along with all supporting documentation and rulings.
Do you have any questions before we get started?
Yeah.
Who the hell are you?
I'm Walter Cofield. Chief of Neurology, Mercy Hospital.
I'll be deciding your fate today.
Cofield.
You were the Residency Director at Hopkins before you moved to Mercy.
Which means it's safe to assume that you trained Foreman.
Which means it's also safe to assume that he trusts you.
This hearing isn't about me, Dr. House.
I know you'd like to make it about me
because then it wouldn't be about you.
It's interesting that he picked the old mentor to judge the new one.
Interesting, but not relevant.
The facts of this case,
on the other hand... - The facts are in the file.
If you have trouble reading my handwriting, give me a call.
I'm going back to work.
If I just consider the file, the facts aren't in your favor.
The facts say you should be suspended.
Which, from what I understand,
would mean a revocation of your parole.
The patient was a 32-year-old high school chemistry teacher.
He collapsed while out jogging.
He was paralyzed in all four extremities
despite the fact that the scans...
...show no sign of stroke or structural lesions.
Did you put out an APB for a car
with a man-shaped dent in the grill?
No broken bones, no signs of trauma.
Transverse myelitis. Boring.
No enhancement on the MRI.
I just don't know what to do.
Please, you have to help me solve this thing.
A little poetic license.
What are you doing?
Taking my vic-amins.
Those are Vicodin?
Did you have surgery recently?
About a decade ago.
My leg is no good at judging time.
Were you taking Vicodin during this case?
(SIGHING) Uh...
Yes.
And during about nine years' previous cases.
(CLATTERING)
My process is proven.
Good things usually happen. Bad things sometimes happen.
And when bad things happen, we should figure out what went wrong
so we can learn from it and correct it.
So we can assign blame.
Instead of recognizing that bad things sometimes happen.
It was nobody's fault.
And then what happened?
Those who can, do. Those who can't, teach.
Those who can't teach, teach gym.
And those who can't move their arms or legs teach us to laugh at others.
House actually presented the case in that way?
Or are you just trying to make him look bad?
Why would I be trying to make him look bad?
Could be your not-so-subtle way
of implying this was House's fault.
Given what's happened, it's understandable
that your opinion would color your testimony.
But I just want to know what you said, what you did
and what you were thinking at the time.
I don't think it was his fault.
Just tell me your initial theory.
I thought the patient had a liver problem.
Hepatic encephalopathy explained why he passed out,
why he couldn't move his limbs.
But that's not the idea House went with?
He thought Taub's idea was stupid.
And what about your idea?
He thought that was stupid, too.
(LAUGHS)
No. I meant, what was it?
Oh. I thought the patient had normal pressure hydrocephalus.
And why did House think that was stupid?
HOUSE: Oh, come on.
Unless you're an idiot, you know why I thought Park was an idiot.
The patient had low opening pressure on his LP.
That's what I said.
No, you idiot.
The patient had low opening pressure on his LP.
Try unsquinting your eyes and reading the labs next time.
Are you intentionally trying to get me to dislike you?
That wasn't me. The chair squeaked.
You're testifying for the record
that you actually used the phrasing, "unsquint your eyes"?
This is not the place to exorcise your guilt, I just want to know...
I actually used the phrasing "unsquint your eyes."
He's hypokalemic, could indicate a problem with his heart, which would...
EKG was normal.
HOUSE: But, Chase,
a doctor who actually takes the time
to read the lab reports, has a point.
The guy's potassium is off.
Could be thyrotoxic paralysis.
Start him on steroids, PTU, and beta blockers.
Mmm-hmm.
And how did these orange smudges get on the patient file?
Seriously? That's your follow up?
I eat a lot of Cheetos, I forget to wash my hands.
Is my snacking really relevant to this case?
Might be, if these were actually Cheetos stains.
What are they?
Seriously, House?
You're blaming me?
You used Adams' shampoo.
I didn't do it.
HOUSE: It was a harmless prank.
My team is made up of Type A personalities.
They need somebody to break the tension every once in a while.
So this was a team building exercise?
Is that what he called it?
It's what he implied.
House prefers chaos over cohesion.
He believes that disagreement and mistrust lead to better ideas.
He's not wrong.
As opposed to being right?
So you treated with steroids.
- And then what happened? - They worked.
Our patient woke up.
EMILY: Bill?
Can you hear me?
Yeah.
I'm thirsty.
That's normal. You've been in a coma for several hours.
Can you tell me your name?
Bill. Bill Koppelman.
Can you tell me what happened to me?
We're treating you for an overactive thyroid.
We think that's why you passed out and couldn't move.
Can you wiggle your fingers for me?
Is he going to be okay?
Excuse me, but only family members are allowed.
It's okay. They're my students.
Everyone back at school is so worried about you.
Is he sick because of the explosion?
What explosion? What explosion?
A chemistry demonstration he was doing for his class went wrong.
Then why was it not already in the patient history?
Because the patient was unconscious.
But I'm assuming Dr. House spoke to the wife.
The wife didn't know about the explosion.
And I was the one who questioned her.
So if there was an oversight, it was mine.
Does Dr. House not attach importance to patient histories?
No. He thinks they're crucial.
He just doesn't think being in the same room as the patient is crucial.
House thinks avoiding patients
allows him to stay as objective as possible.
He's not wrong.
That sounds like a very diplomatic way of saying he's lazy.
That's also true.
Either way, I'm covered.
If you want an accurate patient history,
don't ever talk to the patient.
Everybody lies.
Except me.
To you.
Would never do that.
Okay. Say you're right.
If you had actually been in the room questioning the patient,
you could read body language,
you could ask follow up questions,
and warn him of the cost of lying to you.
Don't forget thumbscrews.
Can you dispute the possibility
that had you visited the patient sooner, maybe talked to the wife,
been directed to one of the students,
that this case might have ended very differently?
BILL: It wasn't exactly an explosion.
It was a controlled reaction that went a little haywire.
JORDAN: It was, too, an explosion.
Simon Harris filmed the whole thing on his camera phone
and posted it on YouTube.
It got, like, over 75,000 hits already.
Looks like you've gone viral, hon.
(GAGGING)
(RETCHING)
He had a loss of consciousness, temporary paralysis,
but when I was told that the patient coughed up blood,
things really started to get interesting.
Your patient was doubled over in pain and coughing up blood.
And you found that interesting?
Why, is that bad?
It's interesting.
I do this demonstration every year.
But I usually have a student aide help me set it up.
Apparently this year he added extra hydrofluoric acid,
which is why it exploded.
The student aide was just trying to make a viral video,
not hurt anyone.
Ended up doing both.
So we figured the patient inhaled the extra large dose
of hydrofluoric acid, and...
...burned his lungs, which is why he coughed up blood.
If only burnt lungs explained the passing out and paralysis.
The explosion does. Check out the video again.
He smacked his head against the wall.
If that caused swelling in his brainstem
that would have led to the eventual loss of consciousness and paralysis.
So we discussed it a little longer
and House decided to treat with heparin.
I wouldn't mind a couple more details.
It was aerosolized heparin.
You skipped over the actual DDX,
and now you're averting your eyes.
I'm growing more and more curious by the moment.
(SIGHS)
He smacked his head against the wall.
If that caused swelling in his brainstem
that would have led to the eventual loss of consciousness and paralysis.
HOUSE: Nobody move. Ugh!
He had on a what?
Gas mask.
The stink bomb was Chase's.
He was getting revenge for the orange hair
and rigged it in House's office.
But House found it.
Mmm-hmm.
You can leave when I have an answer.
Might help if we knew the question.
How do we treat chemical burns inside the lungs?
Maybe we can use a bronchoalveolar lavage to wash them out with water.
Sorry, my fault, I should have clarified.
How do we treat chemical burns inside the lungs
without killing the patient?
Silver sulfadiazine works well on chemical burns.
HOUSE: Burn cream would drown him faster than water.
Well?
Aerosolized heparin.
Me “key .
CHI: But that's only experimental,
it's never actually been used before.
Not true.
It's been used in sheep.
Uh-huh.
The guy was going downhill fast.
We needed a treatment that was a slope changer.
So you busted out the sulphur dioxide stink bomb?
It was a team building exercise.
No, it was manipulation.
You were pressuring your team into coming up with unsafe medical ideas
just to get out of that room.
You say pressure, I say inspire.
The usual, safe ideas were not going to work. Aerosolized heparin might.
And everyone else just went along with this?
No. I told House I thought it was a mistake.
And those were your exact words?
I think I might have said "insane."
You thought it was insane and yet you let it happen.
No, I...
If you disagree with Dr. House on patient safety, Doctor,
it is your duty to speak up.
Otherwise, you're equally to blame.
I did speak up. I tried.
And you failed.
And that's why I went to Dr. Foreman.
The heparin could cause the patient
to bleed into his lungs even faster.
It is crazy.
But House doesn't do crazy just for crazy's sake.
If he thinks this is the only way to help the patient...
COFIELD: You did not tell me you were involved in this case
when you asked me to do this.
I wasn't.
The heparin decision didn't have anything to do with the outcome.
If signing off on everything House does is a pattern,
it affects the way House behaves,
it affects the way House's team reacts to the way House behaves.
House
is brilliant.
I give him the benefit of the doubt most of the time,
because I've seen what he can do.
Getting House out of prison
is the biggest decision you've made as Dean of Medicine, right?
And if he's suspended as a result of this hearing,
he violates his parole and he goes back.
And that probably leaves you as former Dean of Medicine.
I suppose so.
You didn't choose me to oversee this
because you thought I could be objective,
you chose me because you thought I'd have your back.
And I'd think twice about making a decision that would get you fired.
Eric,
I'm sorry.
But if your get-House-out-of-jail-free
experiment blows up in your face,
it's not my job to get you out of it.
After you'd administered the heparin,
I see there was a discharge order in the chart.
Yet the patient never left.
House ordered a therapeutic bath first,
to wash off any residual chemicals from the blast
but we wound up finding something.
JESSICA: You have a bit of a rash.
Can you raise both your arms?
We just need to see how far it goes.
BILL: You told me I was gonna be okay.
And now there's still something wrong with me.
It probably doesn't mean anything, but we want to make sure.
Of course you do.
I gotta get out of here. Okay?
JESSICA: Just relax.
Please just let me get out of here.
It'll just take a minute.
We need to get a good look at the rash.
The rash? That was nothing.
Just some irritation from lying in bed all day.
The problem was the patient's brain.
He freaked out.
I gotta get out of here.
- I gotta get out of here! - Easy.
JESSICA: "Freak out" is a little strong.
In my opinion at the time, it was the rash that was going to kill him.
Invasive strep.
Reasonable theory, supported by the evidence.
The evidence pointed to psychosis.
We caused it by giving him steroids when he first came in.
What'd you think?
I thought Park and Adams were both right.
But that their conclusions were both wrong.
The neuro symptoms and the rash
were both signs of an underlying disease.
Together with the lung, it added up to Wegener's.
How does Dr. House handle it when three smart doctors
come up with three different, but equally valid ideas?
I run a diagnostic trial.
HOUSE: Start the patient on high dose steroids.
Multiple birds, single stone.
If Taub is right, then he can walk out of here cured.
If Adams is right, he will spike a fever, get hypotensive,
we can treat it and he can walk out of here cured.
If Park is right and he goes all Cuckoo's Nest on us,
we can cross "brain" off the list...
...diagnose him, and he can walk out of here cured.
Are you trying to make this easy for me?
By your own admission, if you give the patient steroids,
two of the three outcomes could make him worse.
What's making the patient worse was not having a diagnosis.
This was the fastest way to get it.
It was the perfect diagnostic moment.
In light of what happened,
do you still think it was the perfect diagnostic moment?
Yes.
My theory accounted for all the medical outcomes.
It did not account for the disobedience of my own team.
What are you doing?
I think you're right about the strep.
Can't hurt to biopsy the rash while we're waiting.
Thanks.
At the time, it seemed like a good idea.
I know this is hard.
But please tell me exactly what happened next.
CHASE: Draw up a little anesthetic.
JESSICA: Two cc's Lidocaine.
Get away from me!
(GASPS)
(GRUNTING)
Bill, you're in a hospital. Calm down!
(GRUNTING)
Code Grey!
So your position is that your team's disobedience caused this?
That's not what I said.
You said you didn't anticipate their defiance.
You implied that all would have been fine otherwise.
So who do you blame?
Dr. Adams or Dr. Chase?
Or both?
I don't blame either one.
So who do you blame, Dr. House?
(YELLING)
JESSICA: Code Grey!
Get Haloperidol.
TAUB: Got it.
(GROANS)
Oh, my God, Chase!
Prep the OR! Get a gurney. Start an IV!
JESSICA: Come on.
Bleeder's gotta be in here.
- Got it! - Which artery?
It's his heart.
Fortunately, only the knife tip reached the cardiac muscle.
Made a laceration in the left ventricle
about the size of the tip of my index finger.
At that moment, he could only stay alive
as long as my finger plugged the hole.
Hmm.
It could've been me on the floor.
It should have been me.
It was my theory.
I held the needle in front of the patient that set off his paranoia.
If you're looking for someone to blame,
blame me.
Please continue.
Getting some ectopy.
Coming through! CHI: Good carotid pulse.
JESSICA: Regular? CHI: No.
Got a PVC.
Gotta move it, people.
My diagnostic test worked.
It proved that the patient had a steroid induced psychosis.
That's what you took away from this situation?
The brain was not a symptom of an underlying disease.
Your colleague was stabbed.
Are you telling me you didn't care?
How bad is it?
TAUB: Bad.
Patch.
Ready.
I can't take my finger out, he'll bleed.
I don't think he can take it.
HOUSE: Oxygenation's 100 percent.
He's as ready as he's gonna be.
We gotta go for it.
JESSICA: On my count.
One, two,
three.
TAUB: Suture.
Got it.
CHI: BP is stable.
Patch is holding.
What was his heart rate?
He doesn't have one. He's on bypass.
Not Chase, the patient.
You're DDX'ing?
Park, come with me. Taub's got this.
My friend is here because you didn't listen to me.
I did listen to you. Chase didn't listen to me.
At this point, being here makes you feel better,
you're not helping Chase or our patient.
Fine.
So he just walked out?
There really was nothing for him to do.
It speaks to a certain callousness on Dr. House's part, don't you think?
Who cares if House was callous?
Are you going to punish callousness?
But you agree that empathy is a useful quality for doctors?
House is not the problem.
Your friend got stabbed.
He may die from those wounds.
If you had been in that room, maybe that could have been you.
I wouldn't have been in the room.
Implicitly, you just said that Chase was at fault.
We all knew a psychotic episode
was one of the three possible outcomes.
And Chase brought a scalpel in there.
He endangered Dr. Adams, he endangered himself,
and he endangered the patient.
Thank you.
Lungs, rash, and now excessive RR variability.
Go.
It's a hospital. There are lots of doctors that can take care of him.
And your thinking is that only you guys
are qualified to sit in this room, doing nothing?
If you're motivated by caring,
just bear in mind he's a dedicated chemistry teacher
with a pretty wife and adoring students and a baby on the way.
She's not pregnant.
Would it make a difference? Because I could knock her up.
Autonomic dysregulation...
Shut up.
CHASE: Can you guys keep it down?
You made it, bud.
JESSICA: You're in the PACU.
You've been in surgery. The anesthesia's just wearing off.
Did I have an epidural?
No.
Because I can't feel my legs.
(DOOR OPENS)
COFIELD: Dr. Chase?
Robert?
Yeah.
I'm Walter Cofield.
I'm a neurologist over at...
I know who you are.
Good.
You think you're up for answering a couple of questions?
Well, it's not like I can get up and run away.
Wasn't my best joke.
(CHUCKLES)
I'm smiling because for the last 12 hours
I've been picturing you with orange hair.
I dyed it back.
(BEEPS)
Were you angry with Dr. House?
It was a prank, it wasn't uncommon.
So I've heard.
That doesn't mean you couldn't get angry.
Might actually contribute to that reaction.
Can I ask why that matters?
Are you trying to prove that I was distracted,
that my judgment was compromised?
Who do you think was at fault for what happened to you, Dr. Chase?
Again, why does it matter?
You're a smart doctor.
You know what happened here better than anyone
and you've worked with Dr. House longer than anyone.
And I suspect that you've spent
every minute since this has happened
trying to answer that very question.
I don't think it was anyone's fault.
I was angry but I wasn't distracted.
And I think if there's any chance I'm gonna walk again
it's because Dr. House is a genius.
What about warmth? Can you feel the sheets on your skin?
I just said I don't feel anything.
Objectivity, House.
What about posttraumatic syringomyelia?
A syrinx fanned in the subarachnoid space,
blocking the flow of cerebrospinal fluid.
That'd mean the damage was permanent.
No.
Forget the nerves.
House, if it's total paralysis he must have...
Not necessarily.
Think arteries.
Blood flow to his spinal column is cut off.
It's a clot in the radicular artery.
That could be fixable.
Prep a room for an embolectomy
and let's get that thing out of there before it does any more damage.
And if it's not a clot?
Then you can ask Foreman if hospital insurance covers ramp-vans.
You're through the aorta.
CHASE: There.
Sensory level is at L5, it must be the descending branch.
Can I see the monitor?
Stop there. Shoot the dye.
There it is. TAUB: Don't get too excited.
We still gotta get it out, still could have done permanent damage.
Patient does not have autonomic dysregulation.
There's blood in his urine bag. Kidneys are failing.
- House, not now. - Gotta be now.
Foreman's transferring our guy to Princeton General
as soon as there's a bed available.
Says the doctors here can no longer be objective since the stabbing.
In the middle of a procedure that could basically save your life,
House is actually trying to drag people away?
How do you work with a guy like that?
He wasn't trying to pull anybody away.
Everyone had already refused to work on that case.
He knew the answer.
He wanted to check on me. But he needed an excuse.
Otherwise he could be accused of caring.
So your testimony is that
Dr. House's complete lack of concern
is evidence of his deep concern?
Did you just do that?
What?
Wiggle your toes.
Do you feel that?
Congratulations.
It was the clot.
Short occlusion time of the artery,
when the swelling goes down,
you should gain back at least some of the function.
One more thing. Sorry.
You knew that your patient was at risk for a psychotic break
when you brought a scalpel within his reach.
Why did you ignore that risk?
I thought I was right about the rash.
I would do it again.
I thought so.
That's it? "I thought so"?
What the hell does that mean?
You brazenly defied your boss.
Now that happened either because Dr. House
has established that that's okay in his world.
Or his prank war distracted you.
Or House makes medicine a game
and you just wanted to beat him.
Whatever the reason,
it boils down to the fact that you may never walk again
because House created an atmosphere that promotes recklessness.
(DOOR OPENS)
This will be our last round of questions.
I've spoken with Dr. Chase.
You know he regained movement?
No.
(BEEPS)
Are you really this indifferent
to the fact that Dr. Chase is hurt?
Are we going off the record because this is irrelevant
or are you going to hit me?
Why don't you go tell the guy you're sorry...
I didn't do anything wrong.
It's not an admission of guilt.
He's your friend and he's not well.
He's a co-worker.
Co-worker whom you've known for almost 10 years who nearly died.
And who's still scared he may not walk.
Are you going to have me fired for bad manners?
I'm just trying to understand you.
Why a man in your position, with your abilities,
is incapable of shaking the impulse to act like an ass.
Could we go back on the record and get this over with?
(BEEPS)
Put the Vicodin away, Dr. House.
My leg hurts.
(LAUGHS)
Is that supposed to be funny?
Two explosions.
(DOOR OPENS)
We're not done here.
(THUNDER RUMBLING)
HOUSE: Hey! Hold on!
COUMONT: Close it up.
Take him out of there.
Dr. Foreman said you'd try this.
Said to tell you he's no longer your patient.
Hey!
(SIREN WAILING)
Wait.
I have to get to my car. I want to be...
Your husband has a tumor in his lymph nodes.
You've been wrong every time.
Not this time.
The explosion in the classroom
caused the cancer cells to break open.
It's called tumor lysis syndrome.
His body was flooded with an excess of phosphates, potassium, acids,
all kinds of cancerous junk.
That explains the paralysis, the bleeding, the heart and kidney issues.
Everything.
What about the psychotic break?
Turns out we caused that.
(ELEVATOR DINGS)
This is treatable. Okay?
You have to tell the new doctors he needs total body radiation
and plasmapheresis.
Move your cane, please.
Where's Cofield?
He said you walked out.
I'm walking back. I'm not done testifying.
Apparently you were. Said he'd have his decision tomorrow.
(BEEPS)
COFIELD: This case is a fiasco.
I didn't sleep last night.
Dr. House is obviously brilliant.
Well, I think we've heard enough.
But Dr. House is also a fiasco.
If I were to exonerate him,
condone his completely reckless, immature, almost misanthropic behavior,
I would essentially be sending a message
to all the other doctors in this hospital
that it's okay to act that way, and... (DOOR OPENS)
Sorry.
We're in the middle of something. EMILY: I know.
I came to speak with Dr. House,
and when they told me he was in here
I thought I should say something.
I mean,
he wasn't the nicest doctor I've ever met.
Well, I think we've heard enough.
But he was right.
They found the tumor.
They are removing it, and they are starting plasmapheresis.
They expect a full recovery.
He saved my husband's life.
Well, I guess that's it.
Thanks again.
(DOOR CLOSES)
As I was saying,
Dr. House's process is dangerous and inappropriate.
But he is effective.
I've decided that I would be doing this hospital a disservice
if I did anything to change that process.
Congratulations, Dr. House.
This unfortunate stabbing incident is officially nobody's fault.
(TURNS OFF TAPE)
Coward.
Excuse me?
HOUSE: You've got like 20 pages of notes there.
You were expecting to bore us for at least half an hour.
You've got my parole form in here.
You were going to send me back to prison.
House, stop.
Good things usually happen, bad things sometimes happen.
The fact that that would-be widow
came in just in time to sob all over your soft, mushy heart,
and the fact that her husband is going to live,
does not change whether or not I did the right thing.
(CHASE BREATHING HEAVILY)
(EXHALES)
How'd you get the firing wire into the Vicodin bottle
without me noticing?
Why'd I even have to?
What was the point of the orange hair?
Your hair smelled like Adams'.
Since there's no way you're doing her without me knowing,
it means you were just doing her shampoo.
Which means you were out late drinking with some new girl
or because there is no new girl.
You were trying to make up time by showering at the hospital,
but you were too lazy to buy your own shampoo.
So I found a way to let you know to not be late.
You couldn't just ask me to stop being late?
What fun would that be?
None of this is fun, House.
(GRUNTS)
They decided that your being stabbed
was nobody's fault.
They're wrong.
I'm sorry.
Anything else?
I'm kind of busy.
No. That was it.
I've got it.
(CHASE GRUNTING)